First Dance Song
29 Oct
There have been some traditions that we’ve decided to keep for our ceremony(s), some we’ve opted to do away with, and some we’ve adapted to suit what we want. We’ve decided we do not want the typical couple’s first dance. Instead, while we share our first dance, we’d like other people to be there dancing with us, including but not limited to our matron/man of honor, our friend Jenny and my brother, Dave, and their spouses. But I’ve made it clear to all of our friends that I expect them to join us.
But…a first dance there will still be. So we’re trying to decide pick a song. There are a lot that we’ve decided are definitely not what we want (Extreme’s More Than Words, for example), but narrowing down exactly what we do want has been difficult. Every song seems to have become a possible first dance. We were in the car the other day listening to a CD my mother had lent me, and Dana was like, “Go to number 10! I want to hear it! It has a good title.”
Here is the short list of we’re considering so far. As you read this list, you’ll laugh. Yes, I’m serious. Yes, this is our music taste. Yes, it’s eclectic, but not in the usual eclectic way. Some songs are definitely what you’d associate with a lesbian wedding’s first dance. Others…are probably more songs you might associate with our parents. And with good reason – that song from Mom’s CD is on here. But, hey, good music is good music. It doesn’t know an age.
- Power of Two, Indigo Girls. I mean, for us, this is the obvious choice. It’s a beautiful song, easy for not-coordinated me to dance to, and our first date did involve an Indigo Girls concert. Of course it did.
- Every Time I See Your Smiling Face, James Taylor. Dana always says this song makes her think of me. Our relationship has a lot of laughter in it, and it always has. In the first few years of our relationship, it was sort of long-distance – close enough to make it in under two hours, but not close enough that we could drive down for the evening. So we didn’t get to see each other’s smiling faces as often as we’d like, and when we did, well…you get the picture. Lots of smiling.
- This Moment, Melissa Etheridge. It’s off of her Lucky CD. When I heard this song, I thought of Dana immediately. When we were together, I just wanted it to last. I didn’t want to go back home (or her to go back home, depending on where we were that weekend). I just wanted to “stay here in this moment.”
- Could I Have This Dance, Anne Murray. I know. It’s cheese. But it’s so perfect. And it’s a beautiful song. What better song to dance to for your first dance than one that asks if you can dance that way forever? I’m trying to forget it was in Urban Cowboy.
I’ll admit, too, that last week’s episode of Glee made me want to include I Could Have Danced All Night, but I managed to restrain myself.
So…what do you think? Did you have a first dance? If so, what song did you choose? For us, do any of those stand out to you, or do you maybe have another suggestion? But before you insist something awful or embarrassing, remember – if you’re invited to the wedding, you’ll have to dance to it, too. It’s everyone’s first dance with us as a couple.





I am a nondenominational wedding officiant and I perform wedding ceremonies that the couples I work with prefer. I meet with them in person or through the net and phone calls to put together a ceremony that they would like, whether it is religious, non religious or spiritual in its own way. No matter the reason that couples come to me, I am just glad that I can help them out on one of the happiest days of their lives.













